Elvis at 80

elvis gun

As the year in which Elvis Presley would have turned 80 draws to a close, perhaps it is a good time to look back at what has been, by and large, a year not just of disappointment, but also of comparative disaster – and all due to Presley’s own music label.

It is certainly true to say that Elvis’s popularity has taken something of a tumble over the last ten years or so.  The early 2000s saw the success of the remix of A Little Less Conversation, the release and commercial success of the greatest hits collection Elv1s (and its sequels), as well as what remains the ultimate release of the Aloha from Hawaii and 68 Comeback TV shows on DVD.  And all of that is without factoring in over a dozen re-release singles reaching the top 5 in the UK in 2005 and roughly the same amount reaching the top 20 in 2007.  After that, however, popularity amongst the general public seemed to wane – it was due to an infectious disease called Presleyitis which is more often than not caused by a record label releasing so many inane and bland items aimed at the general public that they no longer give a damn.

What do I mean by that?  Well, as of 2015, if you go onto Amazon you can have Prime delivery on brand new, unopened copies of around 100 different CD Elvis compilations issued by his own record company – that’s not including the public domain releases.  By compilations, I don’t mean products such as FTDs or the Legacy Edition series, but hits compilations, rock compilations, country compilations, gospel compilations, and our old favourite, Christmas compilations!  100.  And people thought Elvis’s catalogue was a mess in the 1980s!

Meanwhile, the last few years have brought us a series of “Legacy Edition” titles that have nothing in common with Legacy Edition titles by other artists but are, instead, two albums shoved on a double CD with a few singles from the period thrown in.  We also have the Original Album series of 3 or 5 disc boxed sets of original albums.  Again, with other artists these are just fine – nice, budget reissues.  With Elvis, however, we have one set with the same album included twice, one dedicated to movie soundtracks that also includes Pot Luck, and one that includes Viva Las Vegas, which was never an original album in the first place.  Speaking of soundtracks, the 20CD soundtrack box from a year or so ago was a nice idea, but ended up with songs being listed but missed off the CD, incorrect artwork, and other errors.

So, all in all, 2015, the year of Elvis’s 80th birthday didn’t have much to live up to – and could only be an improvement.  Right?  Wrong!

It all started ominously with the Elvis80 release in Germany, which was basically a double CD greatest hits release (because the public really needed another one of those) with a third disc that included such tasty treats as There Ain’t Nothin’ Like a Song and a remix of Shake That Tambourine which somehow turned out to be more embarrassing than the original version.  Oh yeah, and a duet on Love Me Tender with someone we’ve never heard of.

Then came the news that the world had been waiting for – a Legacy Edition release of the Today album.  Now, don’t get me wrong I actually really like the Today LP – but with Legacy Editions supposedly reserved for an artist’s best work, it hardly fit the bill.  And, to make matters even more strange, Sony went back to the original soundboard tapes of some 1975 concerts and reconstructed from scratch, and remastered, a concert released in 1980 that was in itself reconstructed.  They took the time to do this, but on FTD (the collector’s label dedicated to Elvis) they released some historically important concerts from 1956 and 1961 without even trying to improve the sound that had been achieved in 1998 – which in itself wasn’t an improvement on the release from 1980 and 1984.

But still fans held their breath, because they knew there was something coming that would “make the hair on the back of your neck stand on end.”  They weren’t kidding.  The culmination of this wonderful year of celebration by Sony turned out to be the Royal Philharmonic Orchestra overdubbed on to Elvis recordings.  Wow.  Just what we always wanted or, in Priscilla’s words, “just what Elvis would have wanted.”

Whoever came up with the idea deserves medals for both blandness and stupidity.  It is not possible to hear what Elvis would have sounded like with a symphony orchestra by placing one on top of his vocals.  If he had recorded In the Ghetto with the RPO he would not have used the same vocal phrasings and techniques that he did with just his core group back in 1969.  The vocal performance would have been very different indeed.  This should not be hard to figure out – well, you’d think, anyway.

And so what happened?  Well, someone arranged the new backings – quite what they were smoking when they were doing so is a mystery, as some sound less like they belong on an Elvis record and more like they’re channelling Debussy and Ravel…while Elvis sings Steamroller Blues, no less. Elvis’s voice on the new album might be crystal clear, but the new backings draw attention to themselves from the opening scratching strings on Burning Love to the closing notes of If I Can Dream.  The most horrendous thing about the entire project is that it wasn’t released quietly.  Oh, no, Elvis’s widow – sorry, ex-wife (it’s easy to get confused) – appeared on talk show after talk show in the UK, Sony publicised the release like mad, and the public went out and bought it, making it #1 in the charts.

This is the worst possible result of such an endeavour.  Firstly, it encourages Sony to make more bizarre, boring and bland releases such as this, and, secondly, it means that those who bought it and were buying their first Elvis album are now unlikely to buy another one.  Ever.  The album succeeds in not just being ludicrous and dull (quite an achievement), but it also even manages to make Elvis’s vocal sound worse than it did to start with on occasion.  Just check out What Now My Love.  The RPO arrangement is bizarre, and Elvis sounds awful.  Double whammy.

And that’s it, folks.  In a year when Sony should have been working like hell to release something wondrous on the back of the publicity created by Elvis’s 80th birthday, they provide us with a year bookended by utter crap releases, with a bit of unassuming country music that no-one really cares about in the middle.  Elvis’s 80th birthday year should have been the moment when Elvis rose in stature once more.  Sony will, of course, say that he did, because cash-tills were ringing and the album was a commercial success.  But at what cost?

Elvis Presley: A Listener’s Guide is available through all Amazon stores. 


4 comments on “Elvis at 80

  1. Bootsman says:

    I agree. Especially about the part where you say that the vocal performances would have been different. My thoughts exactly! I especially feel that way about Fever.

  2. Frank says:

    I’m sorry but I completely disagree with your assessment because you are missing one vital component to your argument and all other arguments about Elvis that most fans refuse to discuss.

    I’m speaking of authenticity and legitimacy.

    Elvis’ popularity has not waned due to a mass influx of products. His popularity has waned due to the masses declaring Elvis as an inauthentic and illegitimate artist who stole his clothing-singing style, dance and music from blacks.

    Elvis has been robbed so harshly by critics who now place his artistry in the category of cultural appropriation that he no matter is seen by the public as a legend, a master and an artist, but as A hot button debate about race.

    It is sad to say but until Elvis is reclaimed as an American legend, his popularity will not get much traction. The influx of items is actually a good thing in reminding people of his artist offerings in life. I’m sorry but I completely disagree with your assessment of the “Today” album which is an under appreciated gem of Elvis’ 70s work. Elvis needs to be kept in the consciousness of the product line of only to be brought to new audiences little by little.

    Sad to see that for all of the other groups who are undoubtedly influenced by the roots of the blues (The Beatles, The Rolling Stones, etc) the only artist to suffer the wrath of the music elite is the most popular, Elvis. The music elite rather analyze his music with a tinge of guilt for other more legitimized appropriations of culture and place the blame solely on his shoulders, but if only they would have been there — in the 50s/60s, they would have realized that, just like many pop culture icons, he helped ushered in a movement, namely civil rights, with his snarl, his hip shake and his country blues.

    • Shane Brown says:

      If you are talking of “authenticity” and “legitimacy” why would you disagree with my assessment. What is authentic or legitimate about overdubbing Elvis’s recordings with a symphony orchestra or by elevating the Today album to one of Elvis’s greatest achievements. I agree that Today is under-appreciated, but it is not one of Elvis’s important or best works nonetheless. The Legacy Edition series, in the words of a press release, “are truly albums that have changed music. From Janis Joplin’s legendary “Pearl” to Jeff Buckley’s masterpiece “Grace”, these titles are the pinnacle of what the SONY BMG archives have to offer.” By erroneously elevating an album such as Today (a pleasant enough effort) it is ultimately devaluing those albums that actually ARE Elvis’s greatest work. Anyone picking up a copy of Today, basing it on the description of the CD series, is going to get home and put it in their CD player thinking that this is the best that Elvis had to offer and then wondering what all the fuss was about. If Elvis is to be taken seriously by historians and music-lovers alike, then that has to start with his own label – but perhaps that horse has long bolted, with the internet flooded with cuts from the FTD label which allow us to hear concerts where Elvis is half awake and outtakes from Clambake and Harum Scarum. The truth is that there is far too much Elvis out there, from the sublime to the ridiculous, and if you think that an 80th anniversary disc featuring Shake That Tambourine is somehow not going to affect how the public and critics view Elvis, then you are very much mistaken.

  3. Mister Moon says:

    From the very moment Elvis walked out the doors of the Sun studio in 1955, he was mainly surrounded by businessmen and sycophants who knew little or nothing about his art.

    Still, he managed to be one of the most important artists in the 20th century.

    Sadly, things haven’t changed much – except that he is no longer here.

    But his great achievements will (as The Platters sang) always be there.

    Despite the businessmen and the ex-lovers.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s